In A Back-And-Forth Battle, An Iraqi Town Splits On Ethnic Lines

Nov 16, 2014
Originally published on November 16, 2014 12:25 pm

The mixed Arab and Kurdish city of Zumar in northern Iraq is a window into the fierce battles for territory between the Kurds and the Sunni extremist group known as the Islamic State, or ISIS.

The mountainous landscape is pockmarked with destruction. ISIS took control of the area in August and held it until late October. Then Kurdish forces, with the help of U.S.-led airstrikes, forced the militants back.

And while the so-called Islamic State is gone now, the dispute over this land, rich with oil, is far from over. Kurds and Arabs have claimed the same territory for decades. And now Kurds appear to be staking their claim to all of it.

It's a microcosm of a country fracturing along ethnic and sectarian lines while ISIS preys on historic enmities between tribes, ethnicities and sect to advance its own cause.

In some parts of Iraq, Arabs are forcibly displacing Kurds; in others, Shiite Muslims are displacing Sunni Muslims or vice versa.

On the road to Zumar that reality comes into sharp focus. For nearly a mile we drive by mounds of knee-high rubble. The Arab village of Barzan is gone; not a single house is standing.

Two young Kurdish soldiers, or peshmerga, riding with us claim that when ISIS invaded, the Arabs celebrated. The soldiers say the Arab villagers accused the Kurds of being occupiers and thanked the Sunni extremists for liberating them.

During the fight against ISIS here, U.S.-led airstrikes reduced some of the homes to rubble. The peshmerga blew up the ones left standing.

"The Arabs are not welcome here anymore," one of the young soldiers says. In his mind they are all ISIS sympathizers. "They killed our friends, our family and you think we will welcome them back? Impossible."

Among those killed was the young man's brother.

When we arrive in Zumar, the streets are all but empty. I try to get out of the car on a street of destroyed stores, but a truck of Kurdish soldiers stops us. They say they haven't completely cleared the area.

ISIS rigged the homes with explosives and left bombs hidden in pots and buried underground. They tagged buildings with the words "Property of the Islamic State." But those have hastily been crossed out with praise for the peshmerga now in control.

We drive on and find a family who returned home 10 days ago. Like that village on the road, their city looks like a war zone. Many homes are nothing but rubble, some destroyed by airstrikes, others by Islamic State bombings. Twisted pick-up trucks that once belonged to ISIS litter the streets.

Mohamed and Ahmed Ali are Kurdish brothers; they're among the few families who returned.

"When I came home and saw the walls standing, I kissed the dirt and the walls," Mohamed says. "I never thought I'd see this place again."

But he says, his neighbors, Arabs, have not and cannot come home.

"They are traitors," he says.

His brother Ahmed nods in agreement.

"My neighbor put a gun to my head," he says. The man was masked and he planned to kill Ahmed, because Ahmed is a policeman. But his children wept nearby, and Ahmed's son recognized the masked man's voice as the neighbor. Only then did the man let him go, but warned him to get out of town.

Throughout the city homes are spray-painted with the word "reserved." Others are tagged with the word "Kurdish," followed by a name.

Mohamed explains the graffiti. Kurds who came back and found their homes destroyed by the Islamic State are taking Arab homes to compensate themselves. When they pick a house they write the word reserved on it.

And Kurds who found their homes standing are writing "Kurdish" on the wall, to make sure no one mistakes it for an Arab home and takes it.

Kurdish residents say it's only fair, because they believe the Arabs sided with the Islamic State when the extremists invaded and Kurds had to flee.

Mohamed points to the homes across the road.

"Those homes are Arab and all of the ones behind them," he says. "And they should not come back."

The Arabs of Zumar, who once made up about half the city, are not here to tell their side of the story. Most Sunni Arabs don't back the Islamic State, and many have died fighting the group, which isn't exclusively Sunni Arab.

But the ISIS does seize on historic grievances, like the tensions between Kurds and Arabs. The Kurds appear to be using this fight to seize land and oil that they believe should be part of a future Kurdistan.

Before leaving town, we meet a Kurdish man, Ismael Ali Ibrahim. He's just returned after months of displacement.

He walks us through his kitchen. A rocket pierced a hole in the wall, and glass and gravel cover the floor. One of his kid's toys, a little stuffed Santa Claus, lay in the rubble.

"I don't know what this ISIS wants or where they came from," he says between sobs, standing in his broken home. "I blame politics and the state."

We walk outside by an empty pen that once housed his sheep, and a bulldozer destroyed by a rocket that he once used to make a living.

He doesn't know what he'll do now, but he thanks God for his life.

Despite this war, his desire is for Iraq to stay united.

But when I ask him if his Arab neighbors should come back, he says no: "They were the cause of all these problems."

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

In Iraq, ISIS militants have taken over key cities in the western and northern regions. But ISIS isn't the only factor threatening to break the country a part. There's also deep distrust between communities. NPR's Leila Fadel visited an area retaken from ISIS and found it seething with ethnic tensions.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: (Foreign language spoken).

LEILA FADEL, BYLINE: We're driving towards Zumar in Northern Iraq. This area is a window into fierce battles for territory between the Kurds and ISIS. ISIS took control of this mountainous area of Kurds and Arabs in August until late October, when Kurdish forces along with U.S.-led air strikes forced the militants back. But just because ISIS is gone, it doesn't mean the dispute over this land is over.

Kurds and Arabs have claimed the same territory for decades. And now Kurds appear to be staking their claim to all of it.

We make a stop on the way. We're just outside Zumar, and in front of me is what was an Arab village. And now every house is on the ground, completely destroyed.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: Two young, Kurdish soldiers or peshmerga who are riding with us say that when ISIS invaded, local Arabs celebrated. The soldiers say the Arab villagers accuse the Kurds of being occupiers and thanked the Sunni extremists.

Some of the homes were reduced to rubble by U.S.-led air strikes. And the ones that were left standing, the peshmerga blew up. The Arabs are not welcome here anymore, the Kurdish fighters say. It's a stark sign of what we find ahead. When we arrive in Zumar, the streets are all but empty.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #3: (Foreign language spoken).

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #4: OK, he said don't leave the street.

FADEL: I try to get out of the car on a street of destroyed stores, but a truck of Kurdish soldiers stop us. They say they haven't completely cleared the area. ISIS rigged the homes with explosives and left bombs hidden in pots and buried underground.

Hello. How are you?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #5: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: We drive on and find a family who returned home 10 days ago. Like that village on the road, their city looks like a war zone. Many homes are nothing but rubble; some destroyed by air strikes, others by ISIS bombings. And twisted pickup trucks that once belonged to ISIS litter the streets.

MOHAMED ALI: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: Mohamed and Ahmed Ali are Kurdish brothers and one of only a few families who've returned. When Mohamed came home, he says he kissed the dirt in front of his house and the walls that were still standing. He never thought he'd see this place again. But, he says, his neighbors, Arabs, have not and cannot come home. They are traders he says.

AHMED ALI: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: His brother Ahmed says that when ISIS invaded, he was briefly held at gunpoint by an Arab neighbor fighting with ISIS. The gunman was masked, but when Ahmed's son recognized the masked man's voice, the gunman let Ahmed go telling him to leave town.

I see graffiti on the walls throughout the city and ask what it means.

I still don't understand what Mahjouz is. It means booked, it means reserved, but why are they writing it?

M. ALI: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: Mohamed says that Kurds who came back and found their homes destroyed by ISIS are now writing the word reserved on Arab homes to take them for themselves. They believe the Arabs sided with ISIS when the extremists invaded, and Kurds had to flee.

M. ALI: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: He points to the homes across the road and says those homes are Arab and all of the ones behind them. He says they can never come back. Now the Arabs of Zumar are not here to tell their side of the story. Most Sunni-Arabs don't back ISIS and many have been killed for fighting the group, which isn't exclusively Sunni-Arab.

But ISIS does seize on historic grievances to further its cause, like the tensions between Kurds and Arabs. In some areas, Arabs are pushing out Kurds; in others, Shia-Muslims are forcing out Sunnis.

Before leaving town, we meet a Kurdish man, Ismael Ali Ibrahim. He's just returned today after months of displacement. He walks us through his kitchen. A rocket pierced a whole in the wall and glass and gravel cover the floor. One of his kids' toys, a little stuffed Santa Clause, lay in the rubble.

ISMAEL ALI IBRAHIM: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: Between sobs he says, I blame the state and politics for this. We don't know where ISIS came from or what they want. He says he wants Iraq to stay united. But when I ask him if his Arab neighbors should come back...

IBRAHIM: (Foreign language spoken).

FADEL: He says no. They were the cause of all these problems. Leila Fadel, NPR News, Erbil. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.